A former head of science from Llangatwg Community School in Neath is in hot water after a shocking breach of trust. Richard James Pugh, 41, faced Merthyr Tydfil Magistrates Court for supplying alcohol to a minor, a student at the school. Despite being a respected teacher for 13 years, this incident has tarnished his career, leaving him jobless and facing legal consequences.
The court heard that Pugh, through social media, contacted the young pupil and gave her a Christmas card signed “your best buddy” with a kiss. He went further by slipping a canned cocktail into a gift bag with other items, leaving it in her school bag. When questioned, the child revealed feeling anxious and isolated due to Pugh’s unwanted attention, making school an uncomfortable place.
Pugh’s defence argued he never directly gave her the alcohol, claiming the items were picked up from a classroom stockpile. Yet, he did admit to writing the Christmas card. The court found his story lacking credibility and handed him a £500 fine plus additional court costs and surcharges. Moreover, a restraining order was issued, preventing any contact with the victim for 12 months.
In her impact statement, the student shared the emotional toll of Pugh’s actions, describing feelings of entrapment and vulnerability. Her education suffered, and she feared not being believed. Pugh’s reluctance to accept full responsibility frustrated her and the court alike.
Judge Neil Thomas remarked that Pugh “could not tell the truth even at this late stage”, emphasising the serious damage to professional trust. While he escapes a jail sentence, the repercussions on his future are undeniable. Let this be a reminder of the responsibilities that come with positions of authority and the severe consequences when trust is broken.